Logo of Weathertight Roofing

Weathertight Roofing

  • 8945 South St, Fishers, IN 46038
  • Industrial Roofing
  • 24/7 Emergency Repairs
  • Free Estimates
  • Locally Owned & Operated
  • Warranties Offered
Hours
Mon7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Tue7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Wed7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Thu7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Fri7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Sat7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Sun7:30 AM - 9:00 PM

About the Business

No description yet.

What people say about “Weathertight Roofing”?

There are not enough reviews yet to form a clear opinion about Weathertight Roofing

Recommended Reviews

Overall Company Rating
Excellent 5.0
Out of 59 reviews
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 stars
Show first:
Mike Stanfield
Jul 31, 2025

I really enjoyed meeting and working with Corey regarding a problem with our roof. He was very professional and quickly determined the problem. He then proceeded to complete the repairs immediately, even to the point of performing some preventative maintenance. I will be calling on him whenever I have problems with my roof in the future.

Matthew Rogers
Jul 31, 2025

Start to finish, everyone I interacted with was professional, organized, accurate, prompt, and quite personable. The job was completed quickly and looks great. The crew cleaned up very well, too. Pricing was good. I highly recommend Weathertight - no reservations at all.

Brian Roedel
Jul 26, 2025

Great experience working with the entire team. They were prompt, professional and did a great job fixing our storm damage. I would (and have) recommended them to friends.

Kara Duffell
Jul 18, 2025

Great communication and fast scheduling! Corey came out to give an estimate and was out to fix everything within a week! Our gutters look amazing!

Andrew’s Wizardly Reads
Jul 17, 2025

Fast & professional service! I was given options based on my budget on how to resolve my issue. Great experience

Randy Gray
Jul 16, 2025

Weathertight Roofing Exceeded our expectations. They provided a quality roof at a reasonable price. The entire process was seamless and we highly recommend Weathertight Roofing.

Jerrett Flesher
Jul 14, 2025

They were very fast with the installation and their quote was affordable. Thank you Levi Whitehead and team for the good service

Carla Clark
Jul 12, 2025

Warranty-covered partial roof replacement was completed when scheduled, and with accommodation to my availability. Excellent job blending the old and new roofing materials. Covered in full by warranty, so pricing information was sent to warranty company, not me.

Kristen Barclay
Jul 3, 2025

Weathertight Roofing exceeded all my expectations! Corey and his team were amazing—very approachable and easy to communicate with throughout the entire process. The quality of their work is exceptional, and the product they provided is truly top quality. I highly recommend Weathertight Roofing for anyone looking for reliable and professional roofing services!

Ryan Barclay
Jul 2, 2025

I had an excellent experience with Weathertight Roofing! Corey and his team were incredible—professional, friendly, and super easy to work with from start to finish. The quality of their product is outstanding, and the finished roof looks fantastic. I highly recommend Weathertight Roofing to anyone in need of reliable and top-notch roofing services!

Lesa Faulkner
Jun 14, 2025

Alex from Weathertight Roofing was great! He addressed my issue along with giving other suggestions for my home. The best!

Lee Rose
Jun 4, 2025

Cody was amazing start to finish. He was patient with our insurance company and prompt in getting the team in to do the work and completing it quickly. He also made us feel comfortable with our decision in explaining things thoroughly as this type of work was new to us being our first time. Although I don’t look forward to anymore roof repairs in my future there is no question that I would want Cody and WeatherTight on my team for the win! So grateful for them and the quality of work. Thanks again!

Jonathan Stonebraker
May 31, 2025

Great experience. The guys were prompt and had the repair completed really quick. I will use them again and would recommend them.

Sharon Sowers
May 30, 2025

The team was great to work with!
They were able to come out in no time and completed the work. Will recommend them for sure.

Lynn Coglianese
May 28, 2025

Great company to work with. From returning your initial call to completing the work, everyone was very helpful and explained every step. Bonus, was the clean up !

Cindy Koontz
May 18, 2025

Weathertight Roofing is a class act. Corey was inspecting our roof the day after the storm and promptly had a crew tarp the damaged areas to prevent further problems. From start to finish, the team was very quick and professional - even down to clean up. The only evidence they had been there was on the nicely repaired roof! I would highly recommend this company without hesitation!

David Eubanks
May 14, 2025

Malik and Roberto were great. On time, really nice work done in a timely manner. They took time to
Explain everything they had done and show us the completed work. Everything was cleaned up and looked perfect when the departed.

Zig Zag
May 10, 2025

I was truly blessed by Weathertight
Roofing!!! Lost shingles off of the roof of my house in a storm, they were at my house that next morning by 9 am! Alex Grim has been amazingly patient, understanding, and more than willing to answer any questions I have had and offering help. They had my roof tarped off that same day so I would not have any more water damage to the inside of my home. The whole crew has been amazingly efficient in doing my repairs in a quick and timely manner. Have enjoyed working with them and would highly recommend them to anyone. Thank you all for what you do!!!

Debbie Grove
Apr 30, 2025

Weathertight recently re-roofed our home. From start to finish, we couldn’t be happier. We got an estimate some months before we started the job and they were very good about honoring their estimate. We dealt with Shane and Tyson. They were very professional and their crew was exceptional… very respectful and cleaned up at the end of the job each day and seemed happy to be working.

Lisa Burnett Butzow
Apr 21, 2025

The workers who came to our home were very kind and personable. They did a very nice job and everything was cleaned up when they left. We would not hesitate to use their company again.

Rodney Parker
Apr 21, 2025

I can't say enough about the amazing service I received after the tornado damage to my home last year. I had to have a completely new roof and siding installed, and the team went above and beyond to help. Tyler and Alex were absolutely fantastic throughout the entire process. They were always available to answer my calls and address any concerns I had, which made a stressful situation much easier to handle.

Not only did they handle the windows, roofing and siding repairs, but they also helped me connect with the right professionals to complete the interior repairs. It was a huge relief to have such a reliable team guiding me every step of the way.

The customer service was exceptional, and the quality of the work speaks for itself. My home looks great again, and I’m incredibly grateful for their help during such a tough time. Highly recommend their services to anyone in need of reliable and professional repairs!

Thank you, Tyler and Alex, and the rest of the staff at Weathertight for everything.

ron marshall
Apr 3, 2025

Weathertight roofing is a top shelf company that truly does what they say they are going to do. Expert craftsmanship and superior crew!!

Libby Batt
Mar 21, 2025

We had an awesome experience with WeatherTight! Everyone was easy to talk to and helpful. The project manager was excellent! Definitely recommend these pros! Thank you, guys!

Jamie Owens
Mar 10, 2025

I cannot say enough great things about Weathertight. They have been amazing to work with. They clearly take pride in their work. They made a dumpy old house into the best-looking place on the street and left the yard more tidy than they found it. We are doing a total rehab, so I know we'll have them back for more work. They've already done the roof, windows and siding. Next is doors and maybe some other miscellaneous exterior upgrades!

Jackie Raber
Mar 6, 2025

They came out gave an estimate found a problem during the estimate and help take care of the problem that day. They had excellent customer service skills and kept us in communication with progress the whole time. During the billing process of there was questions from us we had answers that day. If they had questions on payment from INS we were kept informed. IF we ever need anything in the future for roofing needs we will definitely be using this company again.

Tarah Butcher
Jan 15, 2025

Colt is great to work with!! He’s friendly & knowledgeable. Someone you can trust to make sure your job is done correctly!

Katie Wilson
Jan 12, 2025

My family would highly reccomend Colt Mcphearson! He does a fantastic job and genuinely cares about the work he is doing and is very detail oriented! Thank you Colt for being so personable!

Gunner Wilson
Jan 12, 2025

Colt with Weathertight Roofing is a true professional! Communication and attention to detail couldn’t have been better! Thank you for taking pride in your work and exceeding all expectations!!

Glen Stewart
Jan 12, 2025

Any work I’ve had done by Colt McPhearson has been top tier. Not easy to find someone who’s professional, swift on the job, and always provides the best quality. Would recommend 100%!

sam foust
Jan 9, 2025

I could not recommend weathertight enough. We used them personally and they were fast, professional and did a fantastic job. They worked with our insurance company to make sure we paid nothing out of pocket. Because of our excellent experience I have recommended them to several family members who have also hired weathertight and been equally as impressed! If you have any roofing, guttering, siding or window needs, make sure to higher weathertight.

Shawn Stinson
Jan 9, 2025

Dealing with Corey was the easiest process ever. He was very informative and attentive to our needs. We were very pleased with the end result and would recommend Weathertight to anyone considering work in their future!

Brady Ashton
Jan 8, 2025

Unbelievable experience, Colt McPhearson is a complete professional. Great person to work with, did an amazing job and was on point with communication. I can’t give higher praise. This guy is the best.

Jonathan Betz
Jan 8, 2025

Hands down best bang for you buck around. With personal experience with the window man Colt McPhearson himself, I only recommend and will only use this company. Top of the line guy with the top of the line team.

Kelly Sayre
Jan 8, 2025

Weathertight Roofing has transformed our older house into a home with a welcoming feel. We received many compliments. The quality of materials are outstanding and the craftsmanship of the professionals during installation was impeccable. The jobs were completed in a timely manner to our complete satisfaction. We had roofing, siding, guttering and window wraps installed. Weathertight worked with our insurance company and made it seamless process. We highly recommend Weathertight Roofing!
It has been a few months and we are still getting compliments from our community.
KS

Kaitlyn Winkle
Jan 8, 2025

Weathertight Roofing does a phenomenal job. They are very responsive and professional and work hard to help you get the roof you need. They brought a crew and completed my roof in one day. Highly recommend and would use again and again.

Levi Johnson
Jan 8, 2025

I dealt with Colt for some windows. Not only was he very knowledgeable, he also did quality work, and quickly had my windows installed. Would use him again any day.

Bailey Threet
Jan 7, 2025

Colt Mcphearson is one heck of a guy and would go out of his way to help you. Appreciate him and would highly recommend him for his work!

madonna ruby
Jan 7, 2025

Colt was the representative that came out. He assessed the issue and sent estimates for repairs. The service was punctual and job well done. We will keep this contact for any issues regarding roofing, gutters that may come up.

mindi lechien
Jan 7, 2025

Weathertight did our roof and our new windows. They were wonderful to work with! The communicated well and did an amazing job! Colt was so flexible and understand. Would recommend 10/10!

Caden Roberts
Jan 7, 2025

Very respectable company. I had a big job done and they did an amazing job in very respectable time. I would 10/10 recommend to anyone.

Autumn Elliott
Jan 7, 2025

Colt McPhearson came and installed 9 windows for us!!! He did a wonderful job installing the windows as well as wrapping the windows to have a clean finish! When it comes time to replace more windows and our sliding down Weathertight will be our go to!

Evan Foster
Jan 7, 2025

I contacted weathertight roofing for a quote on windows in my house and garage. Colt showed up to my house on time and was very professional throughout the whole process, he answered every single question I had for him and really made it a seamless process. On top of everything he even took the time to interact with my little boy and let him help with some of the measurements! Thank you for the professionalism!

Dakin Updegraff
Jan 7, 2025

We used this group for a house remodel. Their representative, Colt McPhearson, showed up timely and was responsive to all of questions. He professionally installed windows and doors for us, and we've had no issues since. We remodel plenty of homes and would use him every time!

Rodney Mcphearson
Jan 7, 2025

Colt Was outstanding. Very quick and efficient. Maybe the best I’ve seen. He installed all the windows in our house and helped with the remodel in the kitchen and dining room.

Austin Massey
Jan 7, 2025

I would like to give a special shout out to Colt ! Colt came to inspect and replace 4 of my homes windows. Colt arrived early and was prepared to take on the job. Colt provided me information as to why the windows were needing replaced and also provided me information to look out for on my other windows for the future. Colt was very professional and showed outstanding attention to detail. Colt will be my go to window and door guy for the rest of the time I own a home. I was extremely satisfied with Colt’s work and his work ethic. He is very enthusiastic about his work, and was very helpful in working with my schedule to complete these replacements. Great work Colt !

Will Retherford
Jan 7, 2025

There is not another company I would hire to do installations. Specifically, Colt is who completed our door/window job. I cannot express how much I appreciated his communication, effort, or skills. If I ever have another job to get completed again, he is my only call. Cannot ask for a better guy at his job. You will not be disappointed in any work to gets done for you!

Tyler Elliott
Jan 7, 2025

Weather tight is one of the best in the business! They do high quality work at a very affordable price!
Their window guy Colt McPhearson, he has installed some windows for my family and man I was impressed! Perfect install with beautiful aluminum wrap as well! I would recommend this company to anyone!

Steve Raderstorf
Dec 20, 2024

It just came down to purely a budget issue for me after litterally being raked over the coals by two general contractors in a row. Had the two contractors not bled me dry I would have went with Corey even though his solution was more. I'm confident it was probably better. He provided the most complete follow up on analyzing my roofing needs while being totally straight with me on my project. His pricing was completely fair but for my low slope roof his metal supplier would not warranty my job which made him uncomfortable moving forward on that option which I completely respect & appreciate. The company I went with had a manfuacturer provide me a 15 year warranty on my low slope with metal which hit the budget I had to be at. I spoke to several about this project & only one was close to Corey in terms of the knowledge & care he showed to get it right. Save yourself a bunch of time & Call Corey on any siding or roofing projects very thurough & professional!

Kim Meyer
Dec 14, 2024

Unfortunately, the reason we became acquainted with Weathertight Roofing and its owner, Corey Cates, was due to a huge hailstorm that stuck our whole neighborhood. It did major damage to not only our property, but also to our neighbors’ properties. Corey came immediately the next day and surveyed the damages, met with our insurance adjuster as he went around and did an inspection of those damages, arranged all of the repairs on our numerous structures and dealt with preparing invoices for our insurance company. His expertise is unmeasurable, in our opinion. He helped us choose what materials were needed and even put up with me changing my mind several times!
Weathertight has many specialty teams of experienced leaders and workers and each team that was at our house was professional and friendly. They were superb in their work ethics and we looked forward to them coming to our house each day. When one team finished their work, we were sad to see them leave. Corey and Alex, Tyler, Colt to name just a few, became like family members. Speaking of family members, Corey’s father even chipped in and offered his expertise in replacing our damaged flagpole!

Fortunately, however, our unfortunate situation gained us a beautiful new look to our house and an awesome friend in Corey.

You would have to look far and long to find a better company to deal with for your house repairs, whether it is recommending materials for the job, dealing with insurance claims and being there for the customer from start to finish!

Thank you for an awesome experience!

Your new friends,
Albert and Kim Meyer
Muncie, Indiana

Aaron Pohl
Dec 5, 2024

Tyler Parks with Weathertight Roofing was amazing to work with, from initial contact to the final dump trailer load. Everything was delivered and completed as promised and on time. Professional and efficient. Highly recommend to anyone who is in need.

David Lierman
Dec 4, 2024

Had Alex and his team out to repair our roof and fix fascia on the house. Amazing work and great communication let us know what was being done and the cost. Highly recommend. When we have our roofs replaced they will be choice.

James Whitehead
Dec 4, 2024

I had hail / wind damage to my barn and Weathertight Roofing did an absolute amazing job taking care of us! I called Tyler Parks and he responded very quickly to come take a look at the damage and get the ball rolling! Tyler took care of everything and made the process so easy for us! They had our barn back up and looking amazing in no time! Highly recommend them for all of your home projects!

Aimee Hawkins
Dec 4, 2024

We hired Weathertight to do a few different jobs around the house. They quickly came out and provided a very thorough estimate with photos of our issues and a description of how they would fix them. They repaired our roof in a few places, replaced most of the fascia on the house and even repaired an issue with some missing bricks that was allowing squirrels to enter our wall cavity. They did all of this for a very competitive price and in just 2 days. Alex is courteous, professional, and takes job satisfaction very seriously. I can’t recommend Weathertight enough!

Steve Sneed
Dec 3, 2024

When I had roofing troubles, I was super stressed on how I would be able to address the problem. I reached out to Tyler, and in minutes, he had an affordable plan to ready to fix and protect my home and hard earned assets. Tyler was upfront, easy to work with, and knowledgeable about the process/product. Definitely recommend.

Ashlee Ruddick
Dec 3, 2024

I highly recommend Weathertight Roofing and Tyler Parks! Tyler was professional, knowledgeable, and took the time to explain every step of the process. His attention to detail and commitment to quality are exceptional. If you need roofing services, Tyler and his team are the ones to trust!

Jami Whitehead
Dec 3, 2024

Tyler with Weathertight is simply the best! Very personable, quick to reapond, and makes sure the jobs gets done and done right! Appreciate all the work he did getting our barn roof replaced!

Joanna Saleem
Nov 21, 2024

Alex and his crew at Weather Tight Roofing have been amazing. They have helped answer questions, and have provided support through the entire process. I would highly recommend.

nick keaton
May 24, 2022

8 jobs spread out over 3 or 4 years. I have been happy with all of them. From promptness to logistics to quality finish I am satisfied.

Ike williams
Jun 24, 2021

Weathertight Roofing replaced my hail and wind damaged roof. They were prompt in inspecting my roof and preparing a quotation that was fully accepted by my insurance company,. They applied protection to damaged portions of the roof to prevent additional leakage while awaiting installation of the new roofing.

They arrived on the scheduled installation date and completed the project in one day as promised. The found damaged decking, showed me the damage and replaced all damaged areas. They protected all doors, windows and plantings, no damage to anything. They thoroughly cleaned the worksite. They were very detail oriented.

Alex and Corey were easy to work with, answered their phones, and promptly returned calls when not immediately available.. They are very professional.

I am very pleased with Weathertight Roofing, Alex and Corey. I highly recommend them and will use them again.

Call us and get a quote right now Show phone number
137 locals recently requested a quote
  • 8945 South St, Fishers, IN 46038
  • Industrial Roofing
  • 24/7 Emergency Repairs
  • Free Estimates
  • Locally Owned & Operated
  • Warranties Offered
Hours
Mon7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Tue7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Wed7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Thu7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Fri7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Sat7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Sun7:30 AM - 9:00 PM

Companies Similar in Profile

Banner of Knockout Remodeling LLC
Knockout Remodeling LLC Anderson, Indiana
Average 1.0 (1 reviews)
Banner of NFL Exteriors LLC
NFL Exteriors LLC Fishers, Indiana
Excellent 5.0 (18 reviews)
Banner of Gemini General Contracting
Gemini General Contracting Carmel, Indiana
Banner of Exterior Wood Restoration
Exterior Wood Restoration Cicero, Indiana
Excellent 5.0 (7 reviews)
Banner of Kingdom Roofing Systems - Fishers Roofer
Kingdom Roofing Systems - Fishers Roofer Fishers, Indiana
Good 4.3 (6 reviews)
Banner of Beard Roofing and Exteriors
Beard Roofing and Exteriors Carmel, Indiana
Excellent 4.9 (72 reviews)
Banner of Blue Ladder Roofing
Blue Ladder Roofing Fishers, Indiana
Excellent 4.8 (44 reviews)
Banner of Red Bird Roofing
Red Bird Roofing Carmel, Indiana
Excellent 4.9 (51 reviews)
Other Filters 0