Logo of Weathertight Roofing, Inc.

Weathertight Roofing, Inc.

  • 1429 Andy Ln, Caldwell, ID 83605
  • Commercial Roofing
  • Industrial Roofing
  • Financing Available
  • Free Estimates
  • Locally Owned & Operated
Hours
Mon7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Tue7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Wed7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Thu7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Fri7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Sat7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Sun7:30 AM - 9:00 PM

About the Business

No description yet.

What people say about “Weathertight Roofing, Inc.”?

There are not enough reviews yet to form a clear opinion about Weathertight Roofing, Inc.

Recommended Reviews

Overall Company Rating
Excellent 4.8
Out of 60 reviews
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 stars
Show first:
juan valdez
Jun 10, 2025

Used them for a recent job. Tyson and Shane were awesome, kept up on communication and found me the best solution for my budget and needs. Not to forget, roof came out great. Thanks Guys!

Ted Pfenninger
May 1, 2025

We recently had our roof replaced by Idaho Roofing Contractor Inc. It's hard to say enough good about this organization. The work was superb, the cleanup afterwards spotless. A special shout out to Polo and Alex, who oversaw the actual work and Will who bid the project. All component workers and pleasant people to interact with. I would recommend this company without reservation.

Cammie Kern
Apr 26, 2025

We would highly recommend Tyson and WeatherTight Roofing for any roof job! They did a roof repair job for us and they showed up on time, they were extremely polite and they did a great job!

Riki Sears
Mar 3, 2025

We had our roof replaced by Shane and his team, and they did such an amazing job. Our roof was a tough job having 4 layers on it, a leak by the chimney, and needing vents. Our roof was a hazard really. They got the job done quickly with master craft. Everyone was so kind and courteous and answered any questions I had about the roof. We were actually selected for a free roof giveaway by Shane, himself, during December. I don't know of any other roofing who gives to their community like this. We were honestly apprehensive that maybe we wouldn't get the best quality since it was a giveaway, but boy were we wrong. We got a superior product, with a 15 year warranty. They made sure everything was done correctly by putting in extra vents we needed, and making sure our chimney wouldn't be leaking. Did a great job cleaning up. Shane came back to do a walk through, and made sure the team did a top notch job. I really can't recommend this company enough. They give back to the community and really truly do amazing work. Not just saying that. Forever grateful.

R
Feb 10, 2025

I would like to thank Shane and his crew at Weather Tight Roofing for the spectacular job they did in replacing my roof. I couldn't have asked for better.They all we're very respectful and professional Thank you, Denise Duncan

Camelyn Gast
Feb 3, 2025

This past fall our roof began to leak which resulted in needing a large repair. Weathertight has far exceeded my expectations with their kindness and compassion, as well as their knowledge and timeliness. They always show up as agreed and communicate everything along the way. I was never left questioning anything and felt confident in everything we discussed. The job they did was phenomenal! I am forever grateful to have found this company and will continue to use and recommend them in the future.

reese croft
Jan 29, 2025

Tyson and crew did a little repair work for me. They were clean and professional, fast and respectful. Did the work that was needed and left the job site clean

RODENIA BULLINGTON
Jan 10, 2025

our niece Joyce Wilfong told us about how good of job that you done on her roof so we had our done amazing job ,My husband
went up and looked at the work they did was great? Ronald and Rodenia Bullington

M
Oct 7, 2024

We reached out to Weathertight Roofing for an inspection as there was shingles missing. They were prompt in responding and able to take care of our issue on the same visit. With the weather coming we had to ensure our roof is ready for the winter. Thank you.

GJ
Sep 23, 2024

We had Weathertight Roofing come and replace our roof. They were very reasonable. They were very professional and they even came back to see if we were satisfied with the work. They cleaned up after they were done. I would highly recommend this roofing company. They are the best. Thank you Weathertight Roofing

Jim
Sep 18, 2024

Frankie and the Team did an outstanding job removing the old, tired roof at our home. The new Roof they installed has far exceeded our expectations. The products and Professionalism of this crew is second to none. Thank you Shane, it was a joy working with you. It'll be easy to recommend Weathertight Roofing to our friends and family. Two Thumbs Up!

Nick Cofod
Sep 5, 2024

Highly recommended. Shane at Weathertight was great to work with: excellent communication and responsiveness. The Weathertight crew did fast, high-quality work at a fair price.

Ryan Crowley
Aug 13, 2024

Worked with Shane this spring to replace my old roof after recommendation from my neighbor. Gave me multiple options including one to save a bit of money but still quality shingles. Shane did great communicating steps and checking in. Addressed a couple finishing concerns to improve drainages. Crew finished quickly and did a good job cleaning. Thanks!

Doug Craig
Aug 12, 2024

Weathertight Roofing gave us great service and professional results for my roof replacement. They were one of 3 companies that had been recommended to me. Their bid was competitive, and their quote included superior quality shingles (class 4 shingles) according to the online research that I did.

I really value timeliness and good communication on any project, and Weathertight delivered on both. First, the estimate process was completed fairly quickly. And Shane was both personable and timely in his communication with me throughout the process. He welcomed my questions and followed up daily on the work to make sure things were done according to his high standards. He followed up on the details and seems genuinely interested in taking care of the homeowner in the process.

Edgar and his crew who completed the job were also outstanding. They clearly showed attention to detail. The original roof had areas that had clearly been installed by someone who either didn't know what they were doing and/or didn't care. Edgar, in contrast, took the time to do it right; superior quality work that shows.

And, true to their word, the Weathertight crew did a daily clean up and did a thorough clean up and debris removal at the end of the job. They also took measures to protect the house and the shrubs close to the house during removal of the old roof.
The roof looks great! Great value. Great service. Great job!

I can highly recommend Weathertight Roofing

Melissa Wedman
Aug 8, 2024

Tyson came out to look at our roof and gave us a quote for replacement and repairs. He was very honest in letting us know we could get some more time out of the roof with some minor repairs. It was a relief. No other company did that for us. They were very responsive from the first call. We would highly recommend Weathertight roofing if you are looking for an honest roofer. We had the repairs done and when the roof is ready for replacement we will definitely be using Weathertight Roofing.

Lisa Hinman
Aug 1, 2024

Weathertight did a very amazing job on our roof. All of the employees were kind and thoughtful. Shane worked to get our roof done quickly and the attention to detail is top quality. Would recommend them to everyone.

James Elfering
Jul 20, 2024

I was referred to Weathertight Roofing by a neighbor who had their roof replaced through them. Shane came and got back with a quote promptly. My new roof install was done in 1.5 days and the finished product looks great. I would recommend these guys to anyone looking to get a roof replaced. I can see why my my neighbor recommended them.

Shout out to Shane for being so easy to work with. Leaps and bounds better than the other folks I got a quote from and very reasonable pricing.

Bryan Bauer
Jul 9, 2024

Our neighbor was having their roof completed by Weathertight and after seeing their work I gave Shane a call to get an estimate. Shane and his crew did an amazing job and went above and beyond with taking care of small details on the job. Shane was an excellent communicator as we went through the phases of the job and was flexible with changes that were made in the process. The pricing was more than fair and the quality of work was great. Shane and his crew were personable and positive through the process and would highly recommend them if you are looking for a new roof.

Jason Groner
May 16, 2024

Our experience with Weathertight Roofing was beyond amazing! Not only was the work that they did superior, the speed in which they took care of our contract work and their communication sets them above and beyond anyone else in the valley! Our job was done expediently, and the company was also fantastic and gracious to work with when dealing with my insurance company. They were there every step of the way working through our claim, dealing with the challenges that we had with insurance, and held our hand through the entire process. But most importantly, Weathertight Roofing’s communication and customer service is best in class as they provided timely updates until the project was completed. I highly recommend them for your next project!

Bryon Vincent
Apr 29, 2024

I didn't go in to inquire about roofing. I went in there for an interview, but the staff and the owner were very nice and professional.

Mary Gordon
Apr 12, 2024

Weathertight Roofing did an AWESOME job replacing our 25 yr old roof! Shane and his crew were punctual, knowledgeable, fast and left our yard free of roofing debris AND nails! Quality workmanship! We wholeheartedly recommend Weathertight Roofing for everones roofing needs!

Brianne Gregory
Mar 17, 2024

Weathertight is excellent! Shane is absolutely TOP NOTCH in regards to response time, customer service & answering any questions/concerns right away. His crew was so efficient with the entire process, friendly and professional! Highly recommend! ✔️

Tyler Petitclerc
Mar 17, 2024

The roof looks great Shane was awesome and really came through for me they did a tone of little touches that absolutely turned out awesome

Bill Whitsitt
Jan 10, 2024

Shane was very helpful with keeping me informed throughout the whole process of giving the estimate up to the final installation of the roof. I am very pleased with the quality of the product they offer and the crew did a very good job.

Courtney M
Nov 14, 2023

Wow! Impressed with quality work I have seen so far! They offer so many services. Shane has set the bar high for any competition out there. We have officially put Weathertight Roofing at the top of our list when it comes to our roofing needs.

Tyler Driever
Nov 14, 2023

Shane made the entire process very smooth from beginning to end 10/10 would recommend weathertight to anyone looking for a new roof !

Peggy Bosely
Nov 14, 2023

Weathertight replaced our roof 8 years ago and we were very pleased and impressed with their performance. Recently a small unrelated concern came up regarding some drainage so I thought to call them. Lately it has been difficult getting contractors to return a call or even have any interest in looking at a small job. Not these guys at Weathertight Roofing! Within a day of my call, the Project Manager, Shane Gulley, was at my home to access the situation.
He was very professional, polite and knowledgeable. Shane explained what he could do, gave me a bid and in a few days the issue was resolved! In the process Shane kept me well informed of his plan and his time, always arriving when he said he would. I was treated just as well as when they did the full roof in 2015, the same courtesy and professionalism and respect for my property. I was very impressed with Shane and his workmanship! I do recommend him and Weathertight Roofing highly! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Laura Silkworth
Oct 31, 2023

I live in New Meadows Idaho and was planning to have my roof replaced next spring but Shane checked out my roof and told me I at least needed some temp repairs to get thru the winter. This was mid October and I asked if there was ANY possible way they could fit me into the schedule this year. Shane arranged his crews schedules and was able to complete my roof in a day an a half. We were facing forecasted snow so he had 8 workers on my roof on the day one and they worked from 7 am into the dark to get the majority of my roof done and water tight. It snowed the next day. The following day cleared up and they completed the job and cleaned up the site before leaving. They also did some extra repair on my chimney and added some heat tape for me. Hard workers and very respectful of my property, time and neighbors. Shane was very responsive and kept me informed of the schedule. If you have to replace a roof, it couldn't have been a better experience. I recommend them highly.

Justine Cardinale
Oct 27, 2023

Weathertight Roofing did an excellent job on our new roof and gutters! Shane was wonderful to work with and very quick to respond with any questions. The crew was very professional and timely in getting our roof installed. Very happy with the end result!! Would highly recommend.

Randy Tilley
Oct 17, 2023

Shane and his crew did a fantastic job on our roof project. They were very meticulous and left everything looking great after the job was done. I would highly recommend them to anyone needing a roof replacement.

Erica Case
Oct 12, 2023

We had trouble finding someone to do a small repair on our roof. Shane promptly completed the work for a very reasonable price. Hurrah!

Jonni Shockley
Oct 2, 2023

Weathertight is a excellent company to work with. The project manger Shane was very reliable and kept making sure I was satisfied. The crew went right to work and had the roof completed in two days. My property was spotless when they left each night. I also had my gutters replaced and they arranged that for me. I felt the price point was very reasonable. I will recommend Weathertight roofing to anyone I know who is looking for a roofing company.

Alex Asta
Sep 29, 2023

Shane and his crew did an excellent job and went above and beyond our expectations. I would recommend them to anyone and would certainly hire them again.

Luann Denney
Sep 19, 2023

Weathertight is an incredible company. From Project Manager, Shane to Aaron and crew, they beat our expectations. We had a 50 year old cedar shake roof in need of repair on our cabin. The crew showed up at 7:30 am and got right to work. Some of the plywood was delaminating and needed replaced. Aaron got on the phone to Shane and additional material was delivered by Shane without delaying any work. I have never seen a crew work so hard and clean up as they went. They noticed some patch work on existing metal roof that might cause future problems. When the work was all done, the new metal roof was the only thing to show they had been there. I will highly recommend Weathertight Roofing to anyone that wants the job done right.

Everett and Luann Denney

Eric Overgaard
Aug 31, 2023

Job was done in two days. The yard was cleaned of stripped roof very well. Roof was finished nicely and looks beautiful. The Crew was very impressive in work ethic and quality of work. I wouldn't hesitate to hire them again. We are very happy with their work.

Doug Hezeltine
Aug 16, 2023

Weathertight Roofing roofed our home and the experience was fantastic from start to finish! Great communication, competitive pricing, quality work, great employees, & superb roofing product. I highly recommend Shane and the Weather tight team for their expertise and professionalism on the job - THANK you!

pamela robins
Jul 13, 2023

I can't say enough how much it means to me to have found someone with so much integrity. Shane not only came out on short notice, he was able to repair an area on my old roof that other roofing companies missed and said was ok and I continuedto have the same proble occur. He did a very professional job and even explained what was happening and showed me, and explained why it was happening and then repaired it all in the same visit to save me from having to request another day off work. Shane was so knowledgeable and professional. I truly can't say how much I appreciate his honesty, integrity and workmanship. I would Highly recommend him and plan to have him not only periodically assess my roof going forward but trust him to repair any issues that may come up. Thank you so much for restoring my faith that there really still are people with integrity in these tough times.

Theresa Stem
Jul 8, 2023

Our experience was great. Shane and his crew were very respectful and easy to work with. Very pleased with their work. Clean up was fast and thorough. No surprises. They worked with our insurance company and got the job done right the first time. Thank you so much. I would recommend this company to everyone.

Todd Durrant
Jun 28, 2023

I cannot say enough good things! Fast, friendly, and fair! They kept me in the loop with my situation and did right by me in all areas.

Bentley O'Neil
Jun 22, 2023

I had a fantastic experience with Weathertight. Shane was super helpful, communicative, and thorough throughout the experience. I noticed some roof damage on my property and was surprised that it ended up being covered by insurance.

I talked to 2 other companies before choosing Weathertight. The other companies wanted me to sign contracts signing over the insurance claim before I even knew if insurance would cover it or how much they would cover and sign exclusivity agreements – I was feeling like I was singing away my first-born child. They wanted to upsell me, to pay as much as $7,000 over insurance and didn’t even know what insurance would cover yet. Weathertight was able to meet with the insurance adjuster without me signing anything. They also ended up being able to upgrade me to a superior grade shingle with the amount insurance provided on my claim and also needed to replace some decking and fascia.

I felt much more comfortable working with weathertight and their process was seamless. I would highly recommend them. The final product looks great.

Yvonne Gray
Jun 4, 2023

I had a small job I needed to have done on the roof. I am a small older woman and has no business getting on top of the roof so I thought I’d call a roofing company and see if there was any one person come out and do the job for me. Shane answered the phone listened to everything I had to say, And did exactly asked the small job he was asked to do. Anyone who does a good conscientious job large or small is someone I think you should consider for any job you might have. Thank you Shane for the peace of mind.

jay raborn
Jun 2, 2023

Was looking to replace a 20 year old, small 2000 foot roof which was showing its wear. Shane from Weathertight responded the same day I called, assessed the damage and gave me a very competitive quote from the many I had received. The work was scheduled within two weeks and Aaron and his crew finished the project in a day. Shane followed up the next day, patiently answered my questions and ran me through the work performed. Thanks Weathertight for a nice looking roof and peace of mind on rainy days.

Marlia Harnden
May 24, 2023

What a great group of guys! Next day inspection followed by a quite and on the schedule the following week. Not only did they provide amazing and timely service they walked me through every step of the process and took the time to explain everything to me, helping me make best decisions for my home. I can't thank you enough for the amazing service!

Samantha Vickery
May 17, 2023

My husband and I called Weather Tight roofing after we experienced some damage to our roof due to the wind/weather.

We are very impressed with the service and quality of work that they provided.

Shane and his crew were polite, professional, friendly, & fast!

Terry Engelking
May 8, 2023

Out of 4 bids for the reroofing of our home and storage shed, Weathertight Roofing offered the best quality product in the Malarky Vista shingles, the best overall warranty, a and 3 year workmanship warranty. The Letter of Introduction from the company president David Krings with their company ethics can't be beat. The entire staff Jay, Aaron, Shane were super to work with. The job began and ended on the date and times, Aaron the site supervisor said it would. In my opinion, if you want an honest, competent, quality minded company to reroof your home, hire Weathertight.

Bryan Taylor
Apr 25, 2023

Weather tight replaced our roof a few years ago and did a great job. We recently had a tree damage our roof and Shane was out within an hour of calling to inspect and give us a quote. We appreciate such a fast response and look forward to recommending weather tight roofing to our family and friends.

Jason Tuttle
Dec 9, 2021

Great quality, amazing customer service and down to earth honest people. Will definitely recommend to friends and family. Got the roof done faster than I thought possible. Great company.

Mark Drew
May 28, 2021

Chris came to evaluate our roof condition because a solar installation company had said the roof was wearing badly and should be replaced prior to installation of solar panels. Chris was very friendly, forthright and honest in his evaluation. He reassured us that our 30 year roof had lots of life left. I really appreciated his honesty. I would recommend him to anyone that needs an evaluation of their roof.

Coy Mott
Aug 15, 2020

The experience with Weathertight Roofing was 1st class start to finish! The crew that did our tear off and installation was very professional! We couldn’t be happier! Thank you Weathertight!

Wade Johnson
Jun 10, 2020

The whole crew from the project manager to the shingle crew were excellent. Project came in on budget, done much faster and easier than I expected even with extensive framing work after tear-off. Definitley give Weathertight a call for your roofing needs!

Christopher Johnson
Apr 2, 2020

Woody worked in a storm to finish on our project on time! Kept us profitable when others would have walked! Awesome Team. Great Attitude.

Alex Silva
Aug 22, 2019

Recently our 45 year old tile roof started leaking. We contacted Neil Nelson at Weathtight Roofing. William "Woody" Wood visited us, showed us options and evaluated our roofing situation. We soon made a commitment on the products of our choices. The entire process was quickly completed in 5 days. The workmanship is outstanding. We are more than completely satisfied with our new roof and we recommend them without hesitation.

Edd Price
May 30, 2019

Had a estimate done on a job for over $800 when the job was done it took them less than 4 hours to do the job. Making it a cost of over $200/hour. There was very little material used to do this job. When I inquired about this I was told that is the charge we quoted you. Was surprised to be charged so much when the job was so easy and did not take much time. I would expect an adjustment to the bid when a job is over bid. Had there been problems I am sure they would of charged me more. They had my contact information (my personal phone number all so)but never contacted me for a payment. Now they want to blame me on social media for their poor book keeping by suggesting I am not paying them. I replied to them as soon as I was contacted. I did mail them a check.

Jake Henery
May 11, 2019

Weather tight roofing is an amazing roofing company with professional team members. From the first call the team was polite , professional and caring. Their quality of work is top of the line and they stand behind their work 100%. I would recommend them to anyone with roofing needs. In fact I have been telling my contractor friends to spread the world that weather right roofing incredible.

marty davis
Dec 2, 2017

If I could give less than one star I would. For 4 weeks Weathertight roofing has wasted my time. After one week of waiting for an appointment to be scheduled, I called in and was told the person I gave my information to had been fired and they would expedite someone to come out right away. Another week went by and via phone calls, more lip service. On Monday, a new employee met with my insurance agent. Tuesday, I received a confirmation phone call the work would be done Friday (yesterday). Weathertight roofing not only did not show up, they didn’t contact me, reply to my texts or phone call. They’re website states everything they are not. Honest
(really?), free estimate (the employee complained I had received over $500 of his time, no work had been done, just estimate). Winter is here, I’ll have little luck in finding someone available to repair the damage before it is damaged further. Reputable companies do not play these games.

Susie Patterson
May 15, 2017

We have a 1894 Queen Anne Victorian home with a very steep roof. Finding a roofing company to do the work for a fair price was a nightmare. We called weathertight roofing for a free estimate and were very pleased with their quote and willingness to take on a difficult job. The old roof was torn down and the new roof was installed in 5 days. The employees were respectful of our property, very professional and cleaned the job afterwards. The new roof is beautiful!! I would recommend Weathertight roofing to friends and would use them again in the future.

Brandi Barnhart
Apr 8, 2017

Called to report a leak at 8 am in the morning ask that they let us know how long it would before they could come out. I was told by the man who answered that he would have the repair guy out on repairs call and let us know. Our plan was to call another company if they couldn't make it in a halfway decent amount of time. They never called back at all!!

Adam Conger
Sep 28, 2016

I didn't realize when I started looking for someone to replace my shingles that I would only get one place to even come give me a bid in a timely fashion. Weathertight not only came soon after I called, John Fidanza was very knowledgeable, professional and explained clearly everything that would be done when he gave the bid. The crew did an excellent job cleaning up after scraping off two layers of shingles, when they were finished it looked like they have never been here and the roof looked great too! I am very happy with the quick and professional job they did, I would recommend Weathertight Roofing to anyone needing roof work done.

Karen Knudtsen
Sep 4, 2015

John at Weathertight did an excellent job for me! I recommend him highly. He came through when the roofer who did my roof 7 years ago did not. Go with John at Weathertight!!

Greg Johnson
Feb 23, 2015

John was very responsive starting from my initial phone call looking for a roofing quote. He made a great in-person presentation to explain about his product and service. The other companies just gave me a quote over the phone. The finished product looks great. John earned my business by being punctual and taking the time to meet in person. He actually requested the in-person meeting and after I met with him, I made my decision after seeing their product and service. Would recommend and use again.

Call us and get a quote right now Show phone number
137 locals recently requested a quote
  • 1429 Andy Ln, Caldwell, ID 83605
  • Commercial Roofing
  • Industrial Roofing
  • Financing Available
  • Free Estimates
  • Locally Owned & Operated
Hours
Mon7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Tue7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Wed7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Thu7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Fri7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Sat7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Sun7:30 AM - 9:00 PM

Companies Similar in Profile

Banner of Sweet Roofing
Sweet Roofing Pocatello, Idaho
Excellent 5.0 (2 reviews)
Banner of Roof Maxx of Pocatello, ID
Roof Maxx of Pocatello, ID Pocatello, Idaho
Excellent 5.0 (9 reviews)
Banner of SEI Roofing and Exteriors
SEI Roofing and Exteriors Aberdeen, Idaho
No rating 0.0 (0 reviews)
Banner of Sweet Roofing
Sweet Roofing Pocatello, Idaho
No rating 0.0 (0 reviews)
Banner of Korban Contracting, LLC
Korban Contracting, LLC Lewiston, Idaho
Excellent 5.0 (4 reviews)
Banner of Brian Mcdermott Construction
Brian Mcdermott Construction Lewiston, Idaho
Excellent 5.0 (3 reviews)
Banner of Rock Solid Construction
Rock Solid Construction Lewiston, Idaho
Excellent 5.0 (3 reviews)
Banner of K&K Consultants Home Inspections & More.
K&K Consultants Home Inspections & More. Lewiston, Idaho
Excellent 4.8 (45 reviews)
Other Filters 0