I cannot in good conscience recommend this company to anyone. They have just been purchased by a company in Michigan, and there is virtually zero customer service or continuity of care. For three months I was passed from agent to agent in Pittsburgh, then Michigan, then WV, and then cycled all over again. I left more than 30-50 total voicemails over the course of my project without a return call. I would work with a representative for a few days, and then I would be unable to contact them. The next person started the process all over again as the previous agent is “no longer at the company”. Repair crews came out to evaluate what needed to be fixed (after the entire roof was just replaced). Their reports would never get back to the main office, and there was consistently “no record of anyone at our house”.
MHI replaced my roof on a day in February 2025 that was mid 30s, overcast, misty precipitation, and it had snowed the night prior – despite my significant expressed concern. I was never contacted by MHI the morning of if the work was going to happen. It was only when my wife went to breakfast with our neighbor (while I was at work) that we found out MHI was actively working at our house.
The overall quality of the work left much desired despite the cost and MHI’s reputation. I spent > 30 min cleaning up trash and obvious nails, and there were nails left free on the roof. The gutters were littered handfuls of nails/few feet of gutter. There was trash on the roof and around the house, cut underlayment still on the shingles, plastic stripping/release film left attached, and chunks of plywood sitting on the insulation in the attic from where the roof decking was replaced. Lastly, there had been trash/shingle scraps thrown through the ridge (when exposed). This should have been an expected part of clean up. Furthermore, the baffles in the attic that were under a replaced deck board were removed by MHI yet never replaced or offered to be replaced. MHI stated “I never saw it get thrown away, so it’s probably somewhere”.
Within a week, I had to have MHI come out to repair a leaking vent boot. They also cleaned up a contractor bag full of trash left in the gutters and around the house from the initial install. This was to the degree of the workers throwing full pieces of flashing and handfuls of debris out of my gutters that had been left from the day of install.
Within the first month, the shingles were starting to bubble on the front of the house due to improper installation of the ice/water shield. This issue was repaired two months after initial install. Additionally, they had to completely redo my entire ridge vent as it was significantly shortened (to less than 1/3 the length of my house) during install without my knowledge. The repair was only after I called multiple times to request it be returned to its original length. After the initial install, I could see light through the singles that span the ridge cap that are not in the ridge vent, and it significantly concerned me for the potential of water or other precipitation to enter my attic space. I could also see that the roofing/shingle underlayment did not cross the ridge cap in the areas that do not have the ridge vent. Per GAF standards, the underlayment should cross the ridge cap in areas not covered by the ridge vent to the other side of the roof and overlap 4-6” (GAF TAB-R-164). This was additionally confirmed w/ GAF online technical support services, and it currently would be a “warranty voiding” as this would be a misapplication, per GAF.
After spending ~$16,000 and having a full roof replacement and three subsequent repairs, I expected top-of-the-line craftsmanship, integrity, clean up, quality customer service, and an overall seamless experience. However, I am unable to utilize any of those adjectives to describe my experience. The poor quality of work, significant gap in communication/inability to contact MHI, and the lack of overall customer service was shocking coming from a company of this magnitude and reputation.