Logo of Craftsman Exterior Remodeling

Craftsman Exterior Remodeling

  • 38 W Main St, Carmel, IN 46032
  • Commercial Roofing
  • Free Estimates
  • Warranties Offered
  • Metal Roof
  • Slate Roof
Hours
Mon7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Tue7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Wed7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Thu7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Fri7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Sat7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Sun7:30 AM - 9:00 PM

About the Business

No description yet.

What people say about “Craftsman Exterior Remodeling”?

There are not enough reviews yet to form a clear opinion about Craftsman Exterior Remodeling

Recommended Reviews

Overall Company Rating
Excellent 4.9
Out of 32 reviews
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 stars
Show first:
Jennifer Jefferis
Jul 7, 2025

I love my new Pella sunroom windows from Craftsman Exterior Remodeling.
Clayton & the crew (William) did a great job on a very challenging project.
My home is a 1928 Tudor cottage in a historic area of Indy.
The sunroom was originally an open air porch with elliptical arched openings.
No two are alike.
The long wait was worth the custom made arched windows.
Work began as soon as the windows were delivered.
Thank you Clayton, William & crew.
Jennifer Jefferis

Michael Wheeler
Jun 4, 2025

Craftsman provided an extremely thorough quote and when questioned provided the explanation behind each and every line item. This attention to detail made sure that we knew exactly what we were getting into. The crew arrived on site and executed the plan methodically over several days. They were thoughtful and took their time. There was nearly no waste of product nor time throughout their work and the end product is truly exceptional when compared to that of other contractors. If I ever need them again, I WILL be using them again.

Ashley Wheeler
Jun 4, 2025

Craftsman Exterior Remodeling was very easy to work with and provided quality work. Not only was their work great, they were able to fit us into their schedule quickly.

Andrew Scheumann
Feb 22, 2025

I have worked with Clayton in the building industry for nearly 6 years. Since opening his company he has done nothing but provide quality renovations to homeowners across the Indianapolis market. Although I have not had work done at my personal property, I have done numerous site visits on his projects and the proof is in the pudding. The level of craftsmanship is top notch and you won’t find many (if any) other contractors with the knowledge in the residential exteriors trade.

Deborah Corn
Feb 16, 2025

I called for an estimate. They came out took measurements and said they would get back with me. They never did. I even called them about the estimate and said they would get back with me but they Never did. So if they are not interested in the job it would have been nice if they would have just said so.

Kimberly Hostetler
Dec 13, 2024

Craftsman did a fantastic job replacing our windows and interior and exterior trim. The crew was great and we’re so happy with how they turned out. We appreciate the attention to detail Clayton and his team has. Will work with them again in the future!

Nick Hostetler
Dec 13, 2024

Clayton and team was fantastic to work with from beginning to end. Solid communication throughout and we love our new windows and trim.

CALVIN MOORE
Nov 21, 2024

The whole experience was pleasant and satisfying. The skills of the installers impressed. We were brought into the decisions about different approaches to address cosmetic issues.
The property was left clear of any debris.

Debra Steineck
Nov 9, 2024

Very professional. Walk through both before and after work was done. Work was well done and clean up was done well. Highly recommend them.

Sharon Leedy
Oct 21, 2024

Can't say enough good things about this company. They replaced my siding, soffits, gutters and shutters. Clayton explained everything that would to be done and it was....perfectly! The crew was awesome, answered all my questions and concerns. The end product is beautiful. I couldn't have had a better team.. Clayton checked in often at the site and was available to answer my questions by text and his visits. Thank you to Craftsman Exterior Remodeling!!

Brooke Chaille
Jun 7, 2024

The process was smooth and everyone was very thorough and helpful. There were some weather delays and the crew worked late into the night to wrap up the job! We are very satisfied with the work!

Rebecca Rooney
May 26, 2024

Craftsman Exterior did an excellent job replacing the windows and window trim on the front of our house. We would definitely work with them again. Clayton communicated very well throughout the process, and was very clear about the timeline for our project and possible complications (he saw signs of possible wood rot under the old window trim). The crew did a great job! (Pictures show old windows & trim and then the new ones)

jwwalker122 _
May 19, 2024

We are thrilled with the exceptional job that Craftsman did on the exterior of our home. Not only was the workmanship top-notch, but the customer service was outstanding. Clayton and his crew ensured that the job was done right. From start to finish, the process was smooth and Clayton was very hands-on. We are very satisfied with the results. Thank you for a job well done!

Justin Walker
May 18, 2024

Clayton and the Craftsman Team did a complete exterior makeover on our home. Siding, trim, gutters, everything. Couldn’t be happier with the job they did. Already contacting them to replace our back sliding door with new French doors. There’s no one else I’d have do work on my home.

David Will
Feb 28, 2024

We had the pleasure of getting to work with Clayton and Craftsman Exterior Remodeling this past summer and we had an excellent experience from start to end. We had two major projects for our house: getting a new front door (and side lights) and getting new trim and siding. Clayton came to our house and showed us lots of possible options for our these projects, and we ended up choosing a hardy board siding and trim combo, as well as a beautiful glass/fiberglass door. Prior to starting the work, Clayton created a nice 3d model of our house and added our colors/layout so we actually got an extremely accurate representation we could use for HOA approval. Clayton laid out all the options for the price points and we appreciated the bulleted assessment for cost. Regarding the work itself, Clayton has a terrific team. They arrived early and worked all day (often in the late afternoon and evening) to get to the work done on time. Clayton was often on site and was involved with all the decision making that arose during the project, which made us feel very comfortable. We felt they did excellent work, and also worked hard to avoid creating clutter (really didn't find debris at all around our house). During the actual process, we found our house had more rotten wood than we had hoped for, but Clayton and the team did a nice job reconstructing the underlying frame work instead of just glossing over it. In fact, they held fully redo our small porch area which was totally rotten, and had very poor (unsafe) initial construction work. Regarding price, I felt the price we were quoted was fair. Our overall price came out above initial estimations, but this was related to the expanded scope of the project (repairing the porch, part of our roofing, and additional repair of rotten wood) and this additional price seemed fair and appropriate. I never got the sense that Clayton was trying upsell us, and he remained transparent. They did a great job giving us exactly what we wanted, and I felt that we were always in control of the project. Clayton was extremely easy to get a hold of, he gives out his cell number and always responds the same day to texts. About 2 months after completing our door and siding project, we found the door was having minor alignment issues, and Clayton had the team come out and make some adjustments for us (for free) that got our door back to how it should be. We really have no complaints at all, and we are planning to call Clayton again in the near future to help us upgrade our current house windows. We would highly recommend Clayton and Craftsman Exterior Remodeling team for upgrading your house exterior.

Brian Libby
Feb 6, 2024

Craftsman did a wonderful job on our recent siding and windows project - they were responsive to questions and the workmanship was first-rate.

Kirstan Brazas
Jan 31, 2024

Our house in Carmel, Indiana home underwent a remarkable transformation with a full exterior renovation we had to keep up with all the gorgeous new builds. So happy with Craftsman Exteriors and James Hardie siding. The James Hardie siding not only adds a timeless touch but also ensures durability against Indiana's weather. The craftsman style, meticulously executed by skilled professionals, brings out the character and curb appeal we desired. Our home now stands as a charming and resilient oasis —a perfect blend of craftsmanship and style. Highly recommended for those seeking enduring elegance in their exterior makeover.

Ed Hurt
Dec 27, 2023

I have many things to say about Clayron Napier and the company Craftsman Exterior Remodeling. From the bid which was very competitive. He has done everything possible to get our siding project going. He did things for us no other company even thought about telling us. Scammers are out there and beware. Beautiful siding ...if you need a remodeling outside these folks make it a valuable improvement to our home. Best siding I have ever seen.
Edward B Hurt
Indianapolis NW Side

Ray Hamel
Dec 21, 2023

We recently had Craftsman Exterior Remodeling replace our white vinyl siding with James Hardie Aged Pewter siding and trim. Craftsman did a wonderful job and we could not be more pleased with the results. We've received lots of compliments from our neighbors and we've told everyone we would highly recommend this company. The crew arrived on time, took pride in their work and kept the jobsite clean. Clayton was a pleasure to work with and was very responsive to all of our questions and requests. We would definitely use this company for any future projects.

J Cycotte
Dec 9, 2023

Craftsman Exterior remodeling and Clayton as project manager did a great job on our James Hardie siding…fixed all problem areas.. redid our screen porch (painted ,rescreened and resided).
High quality finish work. Very nice and neat crew, too!

Janet Smith
Sep 8, 2023

Initially, I was quite concerned selecting a company for home repairs due to the unsuccessful experiences out there; THANKFULLY, it WASN'T our experience!!!

Our home needed (siding, gutter and fascia replacement) repairs due to a storm. Craftsman Exterior Remodeling (Clayton) assessed the issues, assisted us with the insurance company and was hands-on throughout the entire process. Chloe was available for questions and answers. The installation team was professional, prompt, thorough and tidy for the duration of the project. We're QUITE PLEASED and our home looks great and sound insulated! I would highly recommend their services!

Kimberly Lonaker
Jun 22, 2023

Clayton was fantastic to work with. Very prompt and true to his word. With any question or issue that arose, he was very responsive (even when he was on a family vacation). The quality of work was greatly appreciated. The prices that were quoted and agreed to were very completive and fair. The work started on-time and finished even faster than expected.
Check out the pictures of our beautiful home Before and After.

Tom Mayhill
Jun 9, 2023

Craftsman did excellent work on the siding of our house. I was especially impressed with the Project Manager Clayton who was very knowledgeable and courteous throughout. He did this as issues continued to come up with our home that is 50 years old. He explained those issues and the different ways to handle them in layman's terms making it easier for us to make a choice on a path forward. I highly recommend Craftsman. Thanks again!

Jen Mayhill
Jun 5, 2023

Craftsman Exterior Remodeling was a fantastic organization to work with. We recently had our siding, soffits, and gutters replaced. Clayton is a wonderful project manager with excellent design taste. He made suggestions that not only look great, but ultimately are keeping our home safe. The crew was incredibly friendly, and worked really hard. If we have additional exterior work, we will absolute connect with Craftsman again.

Amy Hammerle
May 24, 2023

Siding & Trim Replacement

Very pleased with our exterior project lead by Clayton N. Clayton's' customer service was excellent as he met with us several times to review the scope of the project and make recommendations. His communication in scheduling and leading up the project was excellent.

Clayton and his team were quick to troubleshoot and fix a few unexpected challenges with a section of the existing trim/soffits. The work crew was very professional, provided excellent workmanship and left no trace once the job was completed.

We would highly recommend Craftsman Exterior Remodeling.

John Hoover
Apr 23, 2023

Clayton and team did a incredible quality job; we are a reference hands down as our house looks brand new. We had siding done and replaced not only the siding, but the trim, birdboxes, OSB and more with aged pewter and linen white on the trim (matched the gutters). We now have only Hardy Backer siding and boards, the only wood left is behind the gutters (Sofet). Here are the pros on the work they performed.

* Clayton took time with us for color selection and explained everything during the design.
* Perfect caulk lines on the siding and trim
* They used Sherman Williams Duration paint (above super level) as included as standard, no one else does this.
* Took their time to do it right, about 6 days total
* Used very high quality nails
* Replaced our front porch too with all hardy backer (wood was rotted)
* Put a tarp under the Construction dumpster to keep driveway clean
* Daily clean up, was good for our dog.
* Worth every Penny!

Thank you to Craftsman Exterior Remodeling Team! We loved your work.

Greg Chalfin
Mar 10, 2023

I just wanted to say the gentleman you sent out this morning was very professional and answered all my questions and was very knowledgeable. He represented your company with integrity and professionalism I was very impressed

Brent Aarons
Feb 1, 2023

After the heavy rain we received over the past few weeks, we noticed a leak from one of our windows. We called Craftsman Exterior Remodeling and they did an outstanding job fixing it. They were able to assess the problem the next day and found out it was an issue with the roof and siding. By the following day we were provided a fair price to fix the damage. The team was even able to fit us in their busy schedule within a week of calling. Upon completion, a detailed summary and photos were provided to show the work they did. We would highly recommend them for any job!

Alea Aarons
Jan 31, 2023

We recently had a leak above an added sunroom in the house we purchased. Craftsman Exterior Remodeling made it right in the matter of a few hours. They were meticulous and on time and very fair in their assessment of the issue and how to repair it. We will be using them again for any future needs!

Dena Napier
Dec 27, 2022

Great company! Replaced my roof, James Hardie siding , and pella windows. Educated me throughout the process. Great Expierence! Use this company!

carl Napier
Dec 27, 2022

Very Professional! Detail oriented. Educated me through the entire construction process. Completed a James Hardie siding and Marvin window project for me- quality was amazing!

David Spindler
Dec 21, 2022

Installed Hardie plank siding on whole house. Excellent service, through quote with detailed explanation and education of product with comparisons. Quality work on the compete job. Would recommend. Considering having them quote some window replacement next spring.

Call us and get a quote right now Show phone number
137 locals recently requested a quote
  • 38 W Main St, Carmel, IN 46032
  • Commercial Roofing
  • Free Estimates
  • Warranties Offered
  • Metal Roof
  • Slate Roof
Hours
Mon7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Tue7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Wed7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Thu7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Fri7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Sat7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Sun7:30 AM - 9:00 PM

Companies Similar in Profile

Banner of Mr. Handyman of Zionsville, Carmel and Fishers
Mr. Handyman of Zionsville, Carmel and Fishers Carmel, Indiana
Excellent 4.9 (61 reviews)
Banner of Home Property Care Group
Home Property Care Group Carmel, Indiana
Excellent 5.0 (7 reviews)
Banner of Blue Ladder Roofing
Blue Ladder Roofing Carmel, Indiana
No rating 0.0 (0 reviews)
Banner of HomeStar Services and Contracting
HomeStar Services and Contracting Carmel, Indiana
Excellent 5.0 (20 reviews)
Banner of Ace Home Exteriors
Ace Home Exteriors Elwood, Indiana
No rating 0.0 (0 reviews)
Banner of B & B Seamless Gutters LLC
B & B Seamless Gutters LLC Elwood, Indiana
Excellent 5.0 (4 reviews)
Banner of North Indy Roofing
North Indy Roofing Carmel, Indiana
No rating 0.0 (0 reviews)
Banner of Oak Ridge Roofing and Siding
Oak Ridge Roofing and Siding Carmel, Indiana
No rating 0.0 (0 reviews)
Other Filters 0