Update: The GM came out and did the 25 point one year inspection himself and offered to come out and clean my gutters this fall for free. There is no going back in time to change the experience but they do show a commitment to making things right and I very much appreciate the straightforward and honest approach
I have to start this off by saying I like the roof. I did not care for the experience. Things could be different had they chosen not to put my roof on in the middle of a 4-day snowstorm, but that is what happened.
The work was scheduled to start on a Monday. On the Friday before, I got a call from the project lead asking if I could leave work and pull his truck and trailer out of where he had run it into the snow. I work an hour away. This was not possible, despite his suggestion that I leave work anyway. I managed to get a friend to the scene, where it was determined it would need a much larger truck with a winch to pull him out.
After getting pulled out, while entering my property, his trailer clipped the 4x4 post that holds the driveway gate up, breaking it. After the job was done, they did provide a replacement post and a couple of 2x4s for me to bolster it until springtime.
It's important to note before this next section that I paid for the premium service, where they guarantee a solid clean-up job after.
Where to start?
They dropped a 6 foot high pile of ice and snow right in front of my front door. And not just right in front of it, but up against it in a manner that made everything that melted come in under the door. When I asked if they planned on removing it, they claimed it was there before they arrived. Luckily I had pictures of right before they arrived showing no six foot high pile of ice and snow with roofing asphalt all mixed in it. To their credit, if begrudgingly, they dispatched a crew to clean it up. Unfortunately, that crew put two holes in my siding while doing so.
To their credit, if begrudgingly, they picked up a couple of spans of siding and repaired it. Unfortunately, they broke my wife's bird bath while doing so. They offered to replace the bird bath, but by this point I just envisioned all the damage they would do while dropping it off - envisioned an endless cycle of damage and repair and decided to break the cycle and forget about it.
On top of all this, the team put about 40-50 holes in my gutters during the job, one right above the front door, which causes a nice little ice hump every winter.
Part of that premium "clean up after themselves" package was that they would clean up every nail from the area around the house. It snowed probably 16 inches in the two-three days they were replacing my roof. They obviously could not do as they'd promised. Every time the snow melted an inch or so, I'd have to go out with a magnet and clean up nails. Hundreds and hundreds of nails. I probably spent a total of 8-10 hours picking up nails. I still managed to get 5 flat tires from those nails in the spring/summer after they replaced my roof.
Finally, the other part of that premium package was supposed to be a one-year inspection of the roof. This has not happened in the 15 months since the roof was put on and does not give me great confidence that the 10-year warranty will be honored.
I like the roof fine. Minus a few awkward cuts/angles, it looks fine. I just would not have paid what I paid or allowed under any circumstances them to do the job during a snowstorm.