Logo of The Contractors Choice

The Contractors Choice

  • 4435 E Chandler Blvd Suite 200, Phoenix, AZ 85048
  • Commercial Roofing
  • Residential Roofing
  • Warranties Offered
  • Slate Roof
  • Hip Roof
Hours
Mon7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Tue7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Wed7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Thu7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Fri7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Sat7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Sun7:30 AM - 9:00 PM

About the Business

No description yet.

What people say about “The Contractors Choice”?

There are not enough reviews yet to form a clear opinion about The Contractors Choice

Recommended Reviews

Overall Company Rating
Excellent 4.9
Out of 41 reviews
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 stars
Show first:
Dan Ruiz
Jun 19, 2025

I started a polyjacking business last year, bought the equipment, got all set up and started shopping for business liability insurance. What a nightmare! Thought it would be as simple as calling any insurance company and asking for it. Not the case, 3 of the big carriers just flat out refused to insure me due to lack of insurance history in the trade????
I was told that Contractors Choice Insurance Agency would be able to help.
Reached out to Josh Cotner (owner) and he made it quite simple for me and explained everything I needed to know. Contractors Choice was the best choice as far as I am concerned. I have since used them for a Workers Comp policy and have insured my equipment thru them as well. When I need anything insurance related. I call and his wife Lori Cotner gets it done for me. She is always extremely helpful and sounds happy to be speaking with you. I can't say enough good things about Josh and Lori and Contractors Choice! If you need business insurance, they are the ones you should call. Trust me, you will not be dissappointed! 5 stars +

Caleb Owens
Apr 7, 2025

Josh and his team are truly dedicated to providing the best service in the industry. Not only is he knowledgeable about all things business related but he truly cares about helping you be the most successful person possible.

John Glah
Sep 3, 2024

Josh and his staff were (and continue to be) great. They have been responsive and the rates I received were extremely competitive. The customer service that I received put Contractors Choice Agency over the top for me. I've already recommended them to several people.

Nick Landry
May 16, 2024

Josh is someone who truly cares, who prioritizes the needs of his clients, and who strives to put the needs of others above his own as he operates his business. He is a blessing, and someone with whom we're extremely grateful to work. If you come across this business and find yourself in need of their services, don't hesitate, they're the clear choice.

Jair Martinez
May 9, 2024

I can only say that from the beginning I was treated with professionalism, they undoubtedly know how to do their job well and quickly.

Greg Pruitt
Apr 16, 2024

Josh Cotner and his team do a great job in the spray foam industry. I have dealt with other agencies, but they really don't understand our unique business. I highly recommend them. Greg Pruitt Rock-Crete Foam Insulators

Michelle Oxendine
Mar 15, 2024

Josh and his office went all out and got my company "Summit Roof Restoration LLC" set up with general liability insurance fast and hassle free! I couldnt find an agent here in Hartsville, South Carolina that could find insurance at a decent rate for our Commercial roof coating business (which is considered a specialty insurance apparently), Josh sure did! Now were back to business helping clients thanks to Josh and Contractors Choice Insurance! Thanks again guys!

Matthew Benton
Feb 27, 2024

Josh and his team are great. Anytime I need anything like bonds, COI's or just need advice. They are very prompt and professional. My company has been doing business with them for around 6 years and I absolutely recommend them every chance I get.

Joshua Eidson
Jan 27, 2024

Because the contractors choice agency specializes in contractor insurance Josh and his team knows everything there is to know about contractors wayyyy beyond just insurance like how to get more jobs, how to send a proposal to a big corporations, how to set up a website, literally anything contractor related they got your back 10/10 recommend to everyone in the trades

Chris Kuhn
Dec 14, 2023

We have used The Contractors Choice Agency for our business for years now and we are very happy with this partnership! Keep up the great work!

greg Varnado
Sep 29, 2023

I met Josh with Contractors Choice in 2007. He is my go to guy for insurance ever since. Incredible staff and Josh is the best. I am so glad we met in business. If you have insurance needs, be sure to call Josh, you will be glad you did.

Danny Ford
Sep 5, 2023

Best insurance company hands down! Easy to work and communicate with, the right insurance for what your company needs and they shop around for the best price.

Jane Sherman
Aug 31, 2023

Josh and his staff provide amazing service. Thankful we found them. Will definitely be doing all of our insurance business through The Contractors Choice from now on.

Tyler Chapman
Aug 19, 2023

Everything is always explained in a clear and basic manner. They look after us so well. Simply put, they're the best.

Ashlee Fisher
Aug 9, 2023

We needed insurance for our Colorado business. I asked around a bit and Josh from The Contractors Choice came up a few times so I decided to go ahead and give him a call. Best decision I could have ever made for my business! He took the time to explain step by and made everything thing so clear right from the beginning! I am so happy we found Josh at The Contractors Choice! They are amazing and you will not be disappointed if you give them a try as well!

Barbara Taylor
Aug 9, 2023

Outstanding customer service, I truly appreciate all your help. I will absolutely recommend your company to everyone ! Thanks again!

Alexander Rios
Aug 8, 2023

Josh ans His Team These guys are absolutely the best in the industry, So easy to work with, Great team and great company. They really stand behind for Anything what we need with quick and professional assistance for my employees, I'm glad to have you in my side

Erik Hostetler
Jul 28, 2023

Very helpful and always goes above and beyond to take care of our business! I have been with The Contractors Choice for many years and plan on many more years of business with them.

Ed Gund Construction
Jul 27, 2023

The office is always ready to help, the website is easy to navigate and they are promptly responsive. Highly recommended!

Justin Ward
Jun 25, 2023

Josh is the man! This guy has been the best addition to my business! Josh has went above and beyond to help me in every aspect of starting my company, he's helped from llc to insurance and setting up for the roc. Thank man!

Precision Insulation and Coatings
Apr 22, 2023

I’ve been insured with josh from the beginning. He’s been a great resource of information. He’s helped me with things beyond insurance and has been a huge help with my business. Josh is a top notch guy ensuring you have the right coverage for your business! Thanks Josh!

Danny Walker
Nov 4, 2022

Josh was able to get me the best rates and coverage for my business! As my business grows, he knows exactly what actions need to be taken to be sure I am covered. I'm grateful to have an insurance guy that cares about my business as if it were his own.

Chad Dowdy
Oct 25, 2022

Destiny with Contractors Choice Agency is a life saver and has worked double time to get our company the bonds it needs all while meeting crucial deadlines. Destiny is definitely a team player and communicates professionally.

Joel Brito
Aug 19, 2022

Excellent service! We had a thousand questions, they had a thousand answers. Chanda was and continutes to be very responsive, we appreciate the quick turnaround!

Matthew Yunker
Aug 11, 2022

Destiny is a rockstar. Any time I have any issues or questions she is on the ball and gets me answer in a timely manner! She goes above and beyond for her clients. I would recommend going through her to get insurance. Absolutely a great experience!

Jeremy Price
May 29, 2022

Josh Cotner helped me understand contractor insurance for my insulation company. I know why everyone in the industry uses him now. Great rates, has a knowledgeable team, and the best insurance coverage. We got our license bond, commercial general liability insurance, and work comp from him.

Thomas Kaszas
Nov 15, 2021

Josh and the team at Contractors Choice Agency are great. They have continued to work with me and help me navigate getting the correct insurance set up for my business. They have were able to save me a lot of money and working with them has been nice and straight forward. Definitely be sure to give them a call when it comes time to set up your insurance.

Shannon Gonzalez
May 7, 2021

I can’t say enough good things about Contractors Choice and Laura!! She is my go to and is always ready to help! Whether is be numerous questions (I can have a lot), certificates or helping with our plans, she is always there and ready to help! VERY professional and on top of things! I would definitely be lost in this world of insurance without her and Contractors Choice!

Reuben Miller
Jun 30, 2020

Josh and his team always deliver. They make it an easy process to insure your business and buildings. Would highly recommend this agency!

Benjamin Heslep
May 18, 2020

Love it. So easy to work with. Great team and great company. I have had them go to bat for me several times. They really stand behind their service and their clients.

Matt K
Feb 19, 2020

This company seemed to be great to work with however when it came time to actual need insurance coverage I learned the hard way that they included all sorts of exclusions that relate to my business so coverage was completely denied. Do yourself a favor and make sure if you do want to do business with them too get second and third opinions and have your lawyer review before jumping into business with them. BUYER BEWARE.

Melvin Miller
Nov 9, 2019

Josh is a great guy and goes out of his way to help his customers! Very knowledgeable and honest! Would highly recommend!

Precision Insulation
Sep 21, 2019

I’ve been insured with josh from the beginning. He’s been a great resource of information. He’s helped me with things beyond insurance and has been a huge help with my business. Josh is a top notch guy ensuring you have the right coverage for your business! Thanks Josh!

michael brant
Sep 3, 2019

Josh is a very knowledgeable guy and great to deal with, if you need insurance this is the man to talk to

James Gonzalez
Sep 2, 2019

These guys are absolutely the best in the industry! Josh, is a true professional, and I'm glad to have him on my side.

Ben
Sep 2, 2019

Josh is phenomenal. Well versed in everyside of the confusing side of insurance. He was able to explain the value our previous agent left out. The difference is thousands of dollars of insurance exposure. Josh simply laid out what was needed to have us covered the way we wanted. No short cutting at all.

Wayne Peight
Sep 2, 2019

The agents at The Contractor’s Choice Agency did an amazing job at meeting our insurance needs in our commercial roofing company.
I highly recommend this service.

Chris Benavides
Jul 21, 2019

Josh will put it all on the line for you! He is an awesome agent that goes above and beyond

First Alarm
Jul 21, 2019

Josh is the man!
I’ve dealt with many other insurance companies, unlike them, Josh had no problem explaining everything thoroughly to me, and taking time to make sure I understood. Not only was he thorough, he’s very easy to talk to. The process was quick and painless. Josh saved me lots of money form the other guys, and I have better coverage!!

Eric Gladson
Jul 21, 2019

Josh works super hard to make sure I have the right insurance for my business. A lot of companies don’t know the in’s and out’s of my industry, but Josh is involved a ton so he knows exactly what we need for insurance and goes to bat for me in securing what I need to be covered.

Josh Palmertree
Jul 31, 2018

Had another insurance company try to get me insurance for my foam rig. They said they worked at it for a week. Called Josh and had it covered in less than 30 minutes. Thanks again man.

Call us and get a quote right now Show phone number
137 locals recently requested a quote
  • 4435 E Chandler Blvd Suite 200, Phoenix, AZ 85048
  • Commercial Roofing
  • Residential Roofing
  • Warranties Offered
  • Slate Roof
  • Hip Roof
Hours
Mon7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Tue7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Wed7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Thu7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Fri7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Sat7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Sun7:30 AM - 9:00 PM

Companies Similar in Profile

Banner of Gomez Construction Group
Gomez Construction Group Phoenix, Arizona
Excellent 5.0 (3 reviews)
Banner of Kasi Home Komfort Engineers
Kasi Home Komfort Engineers Phoenix, Arizona
Excellent 4.7 (33 reviews)
Banner of CVW Construction
CVW Construction Phoenix, Arizona
Excellent 5.0 (3 reviews)
Banner of Wesmor, Inc.
Wesmor, Inc. Mesa, Arizona
Excellent 4.5 (60 reviews)
Banner of PDP Roof Coatings
PDP Roof Coatings Scottsdale, Arizona
Excellent 4.7 (6 reviews)
Banner of Arizona Construction & Restoration
Arizona Construction & Restoration Phoenix, Arizona
Excellent 4.5 (31 reviews)
Banner of Best Option Restoration Mesa Chandler Gilbert
Best Option Restoration Mesa Chandler Gilbert Gilbert, Arizona
Excellent 5.0 (81 reviews)
Banner of Metal Products Co
Metal Products Co Phoenix, Arizona
Excellent 5.0 (9 reviews)
Other Filters 0