Logo of Headley Do it Best Hardware

Headley Do it Best Hardware

  • 841 Indianapolis Rd, Greencastle, IN 46135
  • Residential Roofing
  • 24/7 Emergency Repairs
  • Financing Available
  • Licensed & Insured
  • Locally Owned & Operated
Hours
Mon7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Tue7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Wed7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Thu7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Fri7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Sat7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Sun7:30 AM - 9:00 PM

About the Business

No description yet.

What people say about “Headley Do it Best Hardware”?

There are not enough reviews yet to form a clear opinion about Headley Do it Best Hardware

Recommended Reviews

Overall Company Rating
Good 4.4
Out of 22 reviews
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 stars
Show first:
Triston Fiscus
Jul 15, 2025

I love this place the staff are super friendly and helpful. I am always here purchasing materials for different jobs, and I always have a positive interaction.
Today, I purchased a 12 foot A frame ladder, and the guy helped me carry it through the store.

They also have various equipment rentals at a fair price.

Sincerely, 3 Points Electric

Chris Rady
Oct 21, 2023

Customer service at Headley is second to none. Tony was extremely helpful when it came to plumbing job. He went above and beyond.

Erin Gordon
Jul 3, 2023

Great store! Great hours! Love that they are open till 7pm and open on Sundays. Most small town hardwares close at 5pm and closed on Sundays.

B Kersh
Jun 8, 2023

The young woman with blonde hair at the register was very rude I come here all the time she acted like I was a bother ..... If you don't like your job or have no people skills I suggest you get another job!!! Maybe one where you don't have to work around the public!!!! It's sad I spent over a hundred dollars and can't even get decent service.......

Shawna Bullock
Feb 4, 2023

I don't make it in here to often but it's a great store. They have a variety of items and they are reasonable priced.

Frank Conley
Oct 10, 2022

Frist an last time renting equipment from these folks. Couldn't evening use the equipment aslo the gal was not very kind to my wife when returning. All she had to say is we need to charge for him another day even after telling her it didn't work for i was told it could be used for. Make sure you look at the equipment before renting good chance that you could be getting bad info form them.

Cory Hill
May 17, 2022

They don't have everything you need but they always have enough to make something that will work for what you need.

M. J.
Jun 24, 2021

Honestly, this is one of my favorite places! If there's something for small home repairs and maintenance that they don't have, then I've not found it. Old skeleton key broke to pieces...they've got 'em! Get keys cut that work, they can do it! Need three wing nuts, got 'em! Furniture scratch cover, got it! Door knobs, got em. Toilet seats, got 'em. Need a screen door rescreened, they do it! Need a storm window glass replaced, they do it! Need sand bags for winter weight in your pickup, they have 'em! Need to rent equipment, they've got it!
The store is clean, the staff is friendly, knowledgeable, and eager to help! One of the last old time hardware stores left!

Kelly Lynn Foster Cash
May 27, 2021

Don't look in the screws, the nails, or bolts, nuts & washers for POP RIVETS!

BELIEVE ME, IF I HADN'T OF ASKED FOR HELP, I PROBABLY WOULD HAVE STILL BEEN IN THE AISLE LOOKING AROUND THE SCREWS, NUTS AND BOLTS!

I WOULD HAVE THOUGHT THAT THEY WERE OUT OF THEM!! !

I needed help finding the allusive pop rivets, for some metal work, around the outside of my home, I got a small piece of plexiglass cut, 13 1/2 inches wide X 22 1/2 inches long, for a camper window! I also purchased a 75 piece car fuse assortment, it included some useful items. A fuse puller, plastic storage case, 6-24 volt tester was included with 72 fuses!

I think this was a great deal, with taxes, I paid a total of $33.66, that included (3 items) everything, that I have listed above!

You tell me, what do you think?? Was it a bad deal?, Or a good deal?, Or a Great deal?, Or was that just a very fantastic deal?

I grew up going into this hardware store with my father! So, I really could be very biased with my opinion! But I don't think so, they are always, Very Friendly and Helpful!!

I never have seen anything but Smiles, on their Faces, when I have went in this Hardware Store. It is also family owned and ran.. take a chance drop-in, go see️, if they got something you may need!

Show HEADLEY'S some
❤️ 7 days a week!

I've come to understand, that HEADLEY'S helps: the everyday person, contractors and sub-contractors! Equally!!

Beth Sutherlin
Apr 9, 2021

The guys and gals are always so helpful with helping you find what you need. Been shopping then since I could walk, with my granddad of course, will always shop local first!

Mittens Blake
Aug 24, 2020

Hello,

My name is Tina Blake and I am a property manager and have had the best service and help in all my projects. I am very grateful for a caring staff and the products that Randall carries. Keep up the good work Randall and crew!

Ron Culver
Aug 20, 2020

Very helpful with advice on repairing a fiberglass bath tub. All of the employees were friendly and helpful without being pushy.

Jack Long
Oct 13, 2019

I went to purchase 600' of twisted poly quarter inch rope. They wanted a $107. I knew that I had purchased the same spool of rope for way less than that. So I drove to Harbor freight and got it for $13.99. Maybe they have a poor relationship with certain suppliers, and I can understand that, but what I can't accept is being laughed out of the store

Johnathan Hyde
Nov 4, 2018

Great small town hardware store. High priced but you always have someone there to help you find what you need.

Dawn Query
Mar 30, 2018

Had a key cut for a pad lock, had to go back because it didnt fit. Took lock with me and they recut it and made sure it wirked before i left. Thanks Greg

Bob Jedele
Feb 3, 2018

Great Hardware store. There is always someone there to help you. If they don't have what you want they can have it in two days or less.

Jay Johnson
Jan 27, 2018

Best hardware store in Central Indiana. Helpful and friendly staff. Picking up hardware and supplies is always a pleasant experience at Headley's

HENDERSHOT'S SERVICE CENTER
Jan 22, 2018

Friendly staff, always greeted at the front door. Lots of employees to help me find the screws and bolts that my husband sends me to get. Inventory is always good and usually always have what I need.

Tad Robinson
Jan 4, 2018

I have been a customer of Headley Hardware for more than a decade. The very knowledgeable and friendly staff at this well-stocked hardware store always goes the extra mile in helping me with whatever the hardware issue I present is, even when the sale is just a small priced item. I am always amazed at how helpful, courteous and expert they are. I highly recommend this business!

Brian Black
Dec 31, 2017

Great Service. Good prices. Helpful staff. Friendly and efficient. You can not beat having a well supplied local hardware in town.

Tonja Redding
Dec 27, 2017

Quick friendly service. Not only at the register. They watch to make sure you find what you need. Always ask if you need help. I feel like a kid in a candy store in there. It's always clean and organized.

Doug Cox
Dec 27, 2017

The big box stores can't compete with the service and unbelievable supply of hard to find hardware items. They are always willing to work with you, offer advice and generally get you headed in the right direction. They have saved me many headache with their guidance and finding the right product for the job!

Call us and get a quote right now Show phone number
137 locals recently requested a quote
  • 841 Indianapolis Rd, Greencastle, IN 46135
  • Residential Roofing
  • 24/7 Emergency Repairs
  • Financing Available
  • Licensed & Insured
  • Locally Owned & Operated
Hours
Mon7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Tue7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Wed7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Thu7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Fri7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Sat7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Sun7:30 AM - 9:00 PM

Companies Similar in Profile

Banner of Post X Post LLC
Post X Post LLC Avon, Indiana
Excellent 5.0 (3 reviews)
Banner of ABR house wash
ABR house wash Orestes, Indiana
Excellent 5.0 (3 reviews)
Banner of Brighter Exterior Lighting
Brighter Exterior Lighting Coatesville, Indiana
Excellent 5.0 (19 reviews)
Banner of Brighter Exterior Cleaning
Brighter Exterior Cleaning Coatesville, Indiana
Excellent 5.0 (59 reviews)
Banner of York Chevrolet Buick GMC
York Chevrolet Buick GMC Greencastle, Indiana
Excellent 4.5 (29 reviews)
Banner of PuroClean Disaster Restoration
PuroClean Disaster Restoration Greenfield, Indiana
Excellent 4.9 (69 reviews)
Banner of Al Porter Commercial Painting
Al Porter Commercial Painting Greenfield, Indiana
Excellent 5.0 (3 reviews)
Banner of On Time Restoration, LLC
On Time Restoration, LLC Greenfield, Indiana
Excellent 4.6 (42 reviews)
Other Filters 0