Logo of Hawkeye Mutual Insurance Association

Hawkeye Mutual Insurance Association

  • 315 S 2nd Ave W, Newton, IA 50208
  • Commercial Roofing
  • Financing Available
  • Licensed & Insured
  • Locally Owned & Operated
  • TPO Roof
Hours
Mon7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Tue7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Wed7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Thu7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Fri7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Sat7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Sun7:30 AM - 9:00 PM

About the Business

At Hawkeye Mutual Insurance Association, we specialize in providing comprehensive roofing solutions tailored to meet the diverse needs of our clients. Located in Newton, Iowa, we offer a wide array of services including roof replacement, roof deck repair, skylight installation and repair, gutter services, and various roofing types such as rubber, flat, and green roofing. Our expertise allows us to manage both residential and commercial projects with ease, ensuring that every aspect is handled with precision and care. We pride ourselves on our organized approach and attention to detail, which allows us to deliver durable results that stand the test of time. Our commitment to consistency and reliability means that clients can trust us to complete complex jobs thoroughly, from initial consultation to final inspection. Serving Newton and the surrounding areas, we are dedicated to providing high-quality roofing solutions that add long-term value to your property.

What people say about “Hawkeye Mutual Insurance Association”?

Customer feedback is largely negative regarding this insurance company, with multiple reviews highlighting severe issues related to customer service, communication, and claims handling. Many customers report feeling scammed, particularly when it comes to policy renewals and claims management. There are consistent complaints about lack of communication and dismissive attitudes from representatives. Although a few customers had positive experiences, the overwhelming sentiment suggests a critical view of the company's practices and customer treatment.

What Users Like The Most

  • The derecho wrecked havoc on our house... and did not unnecessarily hold up progress due to lack of funding.
  • Best insurance company hands down. They are actually there for you during the times you need them.
  • I had hail damage done to my roof... they made it a painless experience.
  • TJ, Luanne, Karen and Diane at Hawkeye Mutual... have been taking care of my auto and home insurance flawlessly for 15 years!

What Users Like The Least

  • We have had them since we bought the house but to date they haven’t covered a single issue.
  • They tried to get my escrow to renew the policy... refused to refund my escrow for January to May.
  • There has been lack of communication for us and for my contractor.
  • Absolutely ZERO Communication throughout the entire process, so far.

Recommended Reviews

Overall Company Rating
Average 2.7
Out of 10 reviews
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 stars
Show first:
Joseph Hess
Jan 18, 2025

Complete waste of money. We have had them since we bought the house but to date they haven’t covered a single issue. Essentially I was told they would only cover my house if it burned to the ground. The worst part is when you talk to them they are smug and rude about the fact that they are screwing you over. I’m sorry but knowingly working for a company that does everything they can NOT to cover a claim makes you a bad person. Not one of these people cares about the client but because homeowners insurance is required they just ignore you and act like you’re bothering them.

Gabe Vieth
Nov 23, 2024

Scam alert! This insurance company scammed me. I cancelled my policy in January 2024. They tried to get my escrow to renew the policy in May 2024 when the policy would have renewed. Luckily my escrow account did not pay them. They refused to refund my escrow for January to May, stating that I didn’t sign a cancellation paper that I never received. They even admitted that if I had a claim during that time they would not have covered it because I had another insurance policy. If you want an insurance company that will take your money for no service and then try to steal from you. This is your place. Thank God I never had to file a claim. I could only imagine how bad that would have been.

Erik Nelson
Mar 5, 2024

Just got a letter in the mail stating they are not renewing my policy. not sure why, have never missed a payment and only had one claim during a natural disaster. however they did handle my claim very well when i had them so thats why im not giving 1 star

Tanner Clary
May 18, 2022

After we filed our claim our adjustor was a joke from out of state. I have hail damage everywhere and they claim 1 dent on a tiny spot as vinyl when we clearly have metal siding. They also don’t want to acknowledge the siding that’s pulled away on the garage or dents on house and garage. We also have gutter damage. There as been lack of communication for us and for my contractor. Also Stating things from adjustor that was never stated to me our my contractor.

Dennis Lagrange
Sep 28, 2021

The derecho wrecked havoc on our house and required an inordinate amount of work to get things back, and in some instances, better than it was prior to the storm. TJ Dykstra and the Hawkeye Mutual Team has been an absolute blessing to work with. They communicated well, returned calls and emails in a timely manner and did not unnecessarily hold up progress due to lack of funding. I am very thankful for the work they have done. Well done!!

Allison Murray
Oct 5, 2020

Absolutely ZERO Communication through out the entire process, so far. Not okay! I made a claim just about two months ago. Six weeks after the storm the independent adjuster finally comes out. I googled him and he was sued by the state of Nevada for Fraud a year ago....... And we're now at about two months since the claim was made and STILL NO COMMUNICATION. They haven't replied to emails or given me any answers over the phone when I call. Do Better. 0/10

I get that a natural disaster happened, and it was widespread... but they clearly had no plan to handle an event like this. I mean you could at least set an out of office response to your emails saying thank you, we have received your email.... that would have been better than nothing!

Nicholas Terbovic
Sep 21, 2020

Best insurance company hands down. They are actually there for you during the times you need them. They help you get back to normal, not make you have to beg for help like most every other insurance company. Great rates, even better service.

Tracy Zier
Jul 2, 2020

I had hail damage done to my roof in March of 2020. In less than a week after having a roofing contractor come inspect it, I notified my insurance company. They had an inspector come check it out and said I was good to go. The next week I already received my check. I've never made a household claim and they made it a painless experience. I won't be worried about calling on them if the need arises.
Thank you!

Ryan Riggs
May 26, 2015

TJ, Luanne, Karen and Diane at Hawkeye Mutual / Dykstra Insurance have been taking care of my auto and home insurance flawlessly for 15 years!!! I have NEVER had any issues with claims being paid, policies being correct or coverage being altered in any way unless there was a clearly identified reason. This is an honest and local company that has the highest integrity of any insurance company that I have done business with. GREAT JOB HAWKEYE TEAM!!!

Justine Munger
Oct 18, 2014

My home has been insured with Hawkeye Mutual for almost 15 years. I have never been late with a payment or had any claims. Recently, I was informed that they will not be renewing my policy. TJ, the president, stated that "your house is a dump and we probably should have never been insured anyway". Wow! That is some customer service!! DO NOT USE THIS COMPANY TO INSURE YOUR HOME!!!

Call us and get a quote right now Show phone number
137 locals recently requested a quote
  • 315 S 2nd Ave W, Newton, IA 50208
  • Commercial Roofing
  • Financing Available
  • Licensed & Insured
  • Locally Owned & Operated
  • TPO Roof
Hours
Mon7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Tue7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Wed7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Thu7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Fri7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Sat7:30 AM - 9:00 PM
Sun7:30 AM - 9:00 PM

Companies Similar in Profile

Banner of 5G Construction LLC
5G Construction LLC Newton, Iowa
Excellent 5.0 (5 reviews)
Banner of Integrity Cleaning & Restoration
Integrity Cleaning & Restoration Newton, Iowa
Excellent 4.6 (16 reviews)
Banner of Mr. Clean Powerwashing
Mr. Clean Powerwashing Mitchellville, Iowa
No rating 0.0 (0 reviews)
Banner of Manfull Construction & Property Services,LLC
Manfull Construction & Property Services,LLC Newton, Iowa
No rating 0.0 (0 reviews)
Banner of Zierke Construction
Zierke Construction Mitchellville, Iowa
Average 1.0 (2 reviews)
Banner of Iowa Roof Renew
Iowa Roof Renew Maxwell, Iowa
No rating 0.0 (0 reviews)
Banner of TRENHAILE CONSTRUCTION
TRENHAILE CONSTRUCTION Northwood, Iowa
No rating 0.0 (0 reviews)
Banner of Worth Lumber Co LLC
Worth Lumber Co LLC Northwood, Iowa
Excellent 5.0 (1 reviews)
Other Filters 0