Abby Wilterdink Agency LLC American Family Insurance

Good 5.0 (12 reviews)

601 Center Ave, Sheboygan, WI 53081
Industrial Roofing
Residential Roofing
Financing Available
Free Estimates
Licensed & Insured

Website www.amfam.com

Phone Show phone number

Hours

Mon7:30 AM - 9:00 PM

Tue7:30 AM - 9:00 PM

Wed7:30 AM - 9:00 PM

Thu7:30 AM - 9:00 PM

Fri7:30 AM - 9:00 PM

Sat7:30 AM - 9:00 PM

Sun7:30 AM - 9:00 PM

Leave Review

About the Business

At Abby Wilterdink Agency LLC, we specialize in a comprehensive range of roofing solutions tailored to meet the diverse needs of both residential and commercial clients in Sheboygan, Wisconsin, and surrounding areas. Our services include roof coating, waterproofing, skylight installation, gutter installation, rubber roofing, and shed roof repair. With a focus on versatility and technical expertise, we are equipped to manage complex projects from inception to completion. Our organized approach ensures that every detail is meticulously handled, resulting in durable and high-quality outcomes. We pride ourselves on our ability to provide long-term value through reliable service and consistent workmanship. Whether you are looking to enhance your home or manage a larger commercial project, our well-coordinated team is dedicated to delivering results that exceed expectations. We understand that thorough project coordination is essential, and we are committed to ensuring every aspect of your project is executed seamlessly.

What people say about “Abby Wilterdink Agency LLC American Family Insurance”?

Customer reviews reflect a highly positive sentiment towards Abby Wilterdink and her agency. Many highlight the professionalism, friendliness, and responsiveness of Abby and her team, noting their dedication to addressing customer needs and providing thorough explanations. The communication throughout the insurance process is frequently praised, with several customers expressing satisfaction with the overall service provided. Clients feel valued and supported, contributing to a strong recommendation for the agency.

What Users Like The Most

Abby is the best! Very professional and prompt with an answer to any question.
She was friendly, listened to our concerns, and provided good information.
Abby never missed a beat as she re-worked old policies and initiated new ones.
Abby and her team are friendly, helpful, and take the time to explain insurance.
Their communication was top-notch, keeping me informed every step of the way.

What Users Like The Least

Customers are fully satisfied

Services: Roof Coating Roof Waterproofing Roof Skylight Installation Gutter Installation Rubber Roofing Shed Roof Repair

Recommended Reviews

Overall Company Rating

Excellent 5.0

Out of 12 reviews

5 stars

4 stars

3 stars

2 stars

1 stars

Your Review of Abby Wilterdink Agency LLC American Family Insurance

Your Name

Your Email

What project did you need to get done?

Rate your experience from 1 to 5.

Show first:

Michael Marini

Google review

Jul 13, 2025

Abby is the best! Very professional and prompt with an answer to any question. Thanks for all you have done for done for us.

Cheryl Freda-Jones

Google review

Jul 11, 2025

Our meeting with Abby Wilterdink at her American Family Insurance Agency was very helpful. She was friendly, listened to our concerns, and provided good information.

Paul Fleming

Google review

Jul 9, 2025

Since Abby has become my agent I have had several opportunities to experience her friendly, knowledgeable, and thorough work as we progressed through my adapting a new lifestyle in a new condominium while transitioning from homeowner to landlord of my old one. Abby never missed a beat as she re-worked old policies and initiated new ones.

I would put Abby as a close second to my absolute favorite agent, Pam Buboltz. But that is only because it will be a long time before Abby's term as my agent can match those many wonderful worry-free years I had with Pam.

Steven Weber

Google review

Jun 10, 2025

Abby Wilterdink Agency LLC with American Family Insurance is friendly, responsive, and truly cares about protecting what matters most. Excellent service and knowledgeable support every step of the way!

Jim Krueger

Google review

May 16, 2025

Abby and her team are friendly, helpful, and take the time to explain insurance and costs in the process of reviewing my insurance needs so I can make informed decisions.

Melissa Jacoby

Google review

Apr 23, 2025

Abby is always wonderful! I call her often with the many changing needs of our large family and she is always kind and able to help. Very pleased with the service!

Tiffany Diven

Google review

Feb 28, 2025

There is no one better than Abby. I love knowing that I have an agent that truly values my family, respects our wishes, is never about a sales pitch, and constant goes above and beyond to provide service that is truly unmatched. I highly recommend this agency and promote Abby to anyone and everyone!

Lexie Neevel

Google review

Jan 21, 2025

My parents have been working with American Family Insurance for nearly 30+ years. Staff is so nice. Would definitely recommend them to anyone! 5/5 stars!

LuAnn Walcott

Google review

Dec 17, 2024

Abby is a great agent to work with. She is kind, caring and truly wants what’s best for you! She will go above and beyond to meet your needs. I highly recommend her for all your insurance needs!

Josh Huettner

Google review

Dec 14, 2024

Had some major issues with my roof in a storm. American Family (Abby) and Custom Craft roofing took care of me. 5 stars .*****

Alex Buechler

Google review

Oct 22, 2024

Abby is super helpful and knowledgeable regarding anything in insurance. If you’re looking for a down to earth, patient, and well informed insurance agent - you’ve found the right one.

Morgan Ashley

Google review

Oct 22, 2024

I had the pleasure of working with Abby Wilterdink Agency LLC and I couldn't be more satisfied! They provided me with excellent home, car, and motorcycle insurance, making the entire process smooth and stress-free.

From start to finish, Abby and her team were incredibly kind and professional. They took the time to explain my options clearly and answered all my questions promptly. Their communication was top-notch, keeping me informed every step of the way.

I genuinely enjoyed working with them and felt valued as a customer. I highly recommend Abby Wilterdink and her team to anyone looking for reliable and comprehensive insurance. You won't be disappointed!